Have you ever gone through a toilet leakage problem? Or overflow of tank water in the bowl? If your regularly used toilet flapper fails to last well, then you need to find a top-notch toilet flapper! If so, you’ve come to the right place.
We are here at your service to give you the proper guideline to find the best toilet flappers for your toilet whether you want a cheaper one or an expensive one. We come up with the best results for you and you are at liberty to choose the perfect toilet flapper through our guidance.
Table of Contents
What is Toilet Flapper?
When you press the lever of a toilet to execute a perfect flush, it is a toilet flapper that paves the way to the water in the tank to make it happen. It acts like a valve or gate in the toilet which is sealed normally by the tank water.
The flapper is attached to the toilet lever with a chain. Whenever we press the chain, the flapper gets lifted and the flush valve is opened to allow a tremendous water- flow.
Appeasing Best Toilet Flappers
Good products may just suffice you but the most liked ones may turn into assets. Here are some suggested ones. Go nail it!
1. Fluidmaster 400CRP14 Universal Toilet Fill Valve and Flapper Repair Kit
Why pick it?
Fluidmaster products had been a helpful solution to toilet problems since 1957 for people worldwide. The products are user-friendly, easy to fix, durable, well built. Fluidmaster 400CRP14 is nothing but a new addition to the list.
With a dual tool, this 400CRP14 one gives a proper solution to the cracked fill valve and unnecessary water flow issues. If you want 3.5 gallons per flush toilets or larger, it is the product for you. This is a multi-material product. The flapper consists of a solid frame that prevents it from twisting. The 501 flapper is chlorine-resistant and has Microban that prevents it from bacterial attacks.
It includes a Fluidmaster 400A toilet fill valve and a durable Fluidmaster 501 2” flapper with five a year warranty which precisely solves the fill and flush problems. The valve can be simply adjusted between 9”-14” and the flapper easily fits 2” flush valve toilets.
400A toilet fill valve includes an anti-siphon design. Moreover, the 501 2” flapper, is built of a solid frame and corrosion-resistant materials which helps to prevent leaks in a satisfactory way. With a suitable price rate compared to other similar products, this fill valve, and the toilet repair kit give you the best features you need.
Drawbacks
Basically, there is no major problem with the product but you may come up with some issues like the tank will be filled slowly because of the foam attached to the valve.
This foam generally covers up the noise while flashing. As time goes the foam expands and the tank is filled a little bit slow which is not a big issue. If it bothers you, you can easily remove it and get rid of this problem.
2.Korky 2021BP TOTO Toilet Repairs-Large 3-Inch Flapper
Why pick it?
Korky has always been very professional in producing high-quality toilet parts. This Korky 2021BP TOTO Toilet Repairs-Large 3-Inch Flapper normally fits TOTO toilet models and needs no extra tools for installation and very easy to replace.
This long-lasting 2021BP is made in the USA, Wisconsin. It is made of chlorazone red rubber which fights back bacteria, chlorine, hard water, & well water. Thus all kinds of bacterial and microbe attacks are restricted. So the flapper will not fall down quickly by chemical reactions. Hence, it is more durable than ordinary toilet flappers.
This is made with an oversized sealing surface with a stainless steel chain. It is one of the best toilet flapper chains right now. You don’t have to hold down the toilet lever for going through a full flush. The rubber is very flexible and creates a tight seal.
The design is so universal that it makes your toilet set-up more user-friendly whether your toilet is modern or older and satisfies you with smooth flushes. It is a good solution for your noisy and running toilets. So it’s worth buying.
Drawbacks
The product is only applicable to TOTO models which is its first drawback because you won’t be able to use this in all the toilets. You may encounter some problems like the flapper drops down before the required time for a full flush instead of floating down gradually.
This may take you a 5 sec holding down the toilet lever and this is not a big deal for the features you are getting at such a very reasonable price.
3. Kohler Part GP85160 (Blue Flapper with Float), 2 In. In
Why pick it?
If your toilet is facing a problem like a quick drop of the flapper or overflow of water in the bowl then this product is the solution for you. This 2” Kohler Part GP85160 is supported with a float by which you can adjust your water-flow conditions as desired and have a perfect flush.
With the help of float and chain, you can easily control the degree of water flow. This particular job is done by adjusting the length of the chain. So you can have a quick flush or a large flush or even larger by this chain-adjusting technique.
This flapper is used mostly in 1.6 GPF two-piece toilets and also used in Kallista toilets. This product can be suitable for a wide variety of Kohler models and various two-piece toilets. With this product, Kohler offers you product longevity and high performance with Kohler Genuine Parts.
This multi-material blue flapper has a weight of 1.6 ounces with a dimension of 5.2*2*1.8 inches. The product is worth buying at a very feasible price. So if you are a toilet user that is mentioned in the models above, it is really a good choice for you.
Drawbacks
The product is of no use for you if you are not the user of the mentioned toilet models. The flapper is a bit larger and you may face problems like the whole water of the tank is not being used to provide a full flush. You may find the foamless useful than expected.
But it is seen that a lot of toilets can cope up with this problem as those don’t need the full tank water to execute the required flush. So you can take these issues under consideration while buying the product.
4. Fluidmaster 502P21 2-Inch Universal PerforMAX Longest Lasting, Water Saving Toilet Flapper
Why pick it?
This Fluidmaster 502 PerforMAX 2” comes up with a variety of convenient features for you. It is a water-saving flapper made of corrosive resistant materials and a solid frame that doesn’t bend and can easily fit in most of the 2” flush valve toilets.
This flapper gives you the maximum flush efficiency with a five-year warranty. It fixes most of your frequent toilet problems. The product is affiliated with Micro-ban that prevents the growth of harmful microbes. So the durability is optimal.
The product is 0.16 ounces and 6*6*3 inches in dimension. This product is best-suited with 1.28 HET and 1.6 GPF toilets. It can also work with 3.5 GPF. It is of very low cost, a long-lasting one, easy to install which makes a user-friendly move and allures you to buy it.
Drawbacks
Normally the flapper functions in the desired manner but you may face problems like the flapper is melting. But it will take several years to happen. Your hygienic use of the toilet will also lessen this risk. So this Fluidmaster product is totally perfect for you to buy.
5. Kohler Part GP1078441 Flapper for Two-Piece Toilets with Class Five Technology
Why pick it?
Like all other Kohler products, this Kohler Part GP1078441 Flapper is well manufactured with Genuine Kohler Parts. It is made of a corrosive-resistant material and includes a class five technology.
The body structure of the flapper is made of rubber with a Plumbing Overstock style. No foam and clips are attached to the chain. This product is easy to install and doesn’t any modifications or customizations like universal products.
It is a 3 ¼” toilet flapper, slightly heavier (2.72 ounces) than other similar flappers and has a dimension of 5.2*4*2.5 inches. This Kohler Part GP1078441 Flapper is used in different two-piece toilets and also suited for a lot of Kohler models. It gives a high flush performance with longevity assurance of the product.
Drawbacks
This product is most suited for Kohler models. So if you are not a Kohler user, maybe you will not get the original product performance in some cases. The rubber may not withstand after 3 or 4 years which is not a big deal at this price. You can buy it without confusion if it suits your toilet.
6. American Standard 7381129-200.0070A Universal Flapper
Why pick it?
This American Standard 7381129-200.0070A Universal Flapper is generally suited for 2 “ flush valves. It includes floats and clips along with chain and hook. So the control of water-flow is very precise with this product.
This American Standard product can give you a longer flush if you set the float lower, a shorter flush if you set the float higher. So you see the water-flow can be controlled so easily. You are getting a one year warranty in addition.
This product is black in appearance, weighs 1.6 ounces along with a dimension of 4.8*4.8*4.8 inches. Quality engineering and construction of this brand make the flapper more durable, reliable, easy to set. So you can encounter a better flush experience with this.
Drawbacks
A problem arises with the white plastic clips attached with the float that slip of sometimes. These clips may appear a little bit flimsy. If this happens, you can easily detect them at the bottom of the tank and fix them again. You can also replace them with new ones from the market or old ones from the previous flapper.
7. Fluidmaster 5403 3-Inch Universal Water Saving Long Life Toilet Flapper
Why pick it?
If you are searching for a long-lasting toilet leakage solution with high flush experience, this is the right choice for you. This 3” flapper is easy to install and fits 3” flush valve toilets. It includes a durable silicon seal, a kink-free chain.
This Fluidmaster 5403 is water-resistant. Its silicon seal is ten times more durable than the ideal flapper designs. This product also carries a 10 years warranty. The silicon seal prevents the solid frame build from bending and the 5403’s adjustable water dial ensures the efficient use of water per flush.
This Fluidmaster product has a dimension of 9*4*3 inches and a weight of 2.4 ounces. It replaces and upgrades your old, corroded and leaky flappers. It fits best for 1.28 HET and 1.6 GPF toilets with a 3” flush valve.
This 5403 toilet flapper is mainly composed of plastic and silicon that assures the durability with a lifetime warranty. Getting these adorable features at such a reasonable price is really really appreciating. So you can have a great experience in fixing your corrosion and running toilet problems.
Drawbacks
The flapper is not a universal one. If you are a Toto user or 2” flush valve toilet user, you may face some fitting problems. Moreover, the other parts of the flapper may not last compared to the silicon seal. But normally it will last at least 3-4 years. So you can have a very good experience with this Fluidmaster 5403 except these problems.
8. Korky 2003BP EasyFix Toilet Flush Valve and Flapper Repair Kit – Repairs Flush Valves and Flappers – Easy to Install – Made in USA, red
Why pick it?
Korky’s 2003BP toilet flapper seal repair kit is a great option for fixing toilet leaks and similar problems. It includes just the items you might need to address a leaky toilet tank: a toilet flapper, a stainless steel chain, a plastic flush valve seat, and a silicone sealant tube. You can install the new replacements easily using the given instructions that are quite straightforward. This kit is popular among users who faced leakage issues and could not find anything else that solved the problem. The flexible rubber construction ensures a tight seal on flush valves, and the sealant dries fast and sets well to prevent further leaks – which is exactly what most people needed!
Drawbacks
Though the kit is simple and effective, it can be a bit more expensive compared to other toilet flapper kits. The parts might also not fit all toilet tanks, so make sure that you confirm the specifications for compatibility before buying.
9. Korky Toilet Repair Korky 100DP Toilet Flapper, Red
Why pick it?
This 2-pack toiler flapper set from Korky is a good choice if you are looking for backup flappers. These 2-inch flappers have a universal design that fits various toilets like American Standard, Kohler, and TOTO – generally those that enable 1.28, 1.6, 3.5, and 5 gallons per flush (GPF). You can adjust the required setting to create a perfect fit in your specific toilet tank. They are made of a durable material that lasts long. The pack makes a good replacement option for rubber, float-style, and even rigid-frame toilet flappers if you are experiencing leaky and running toilets and want to reduce water wastage. You can install these flappers easily without any tools.
Drawbacks
Absolutely none so far!
10. DELTA FAUCET RP72472 3″ Delta Toilet Flapper, Chrome
Why pick it?
Delta Faucet’s 3-inch RP72472 toilet flapper is designed specifically for Delta Faucet toilets like the Corrente, Riosa, and Prelude models. The chrome flapper is resistant to corrosion which simply makes it more durable for long-term use. It has been tested for quality results and ease of installation, so you should be able to install it in no time. The flapper is a perfect replacement for the original product and works best for the listed toilet tanks.
Drawbacks
Despite its ease of installation, the actual silicone seal has been a cause of concern among users. It tends to absorb water over time and swell up, which ruins the whole seal around the flapper. This causes leaks and limits the flapper’s usability, especially if you want to solve the already existing leakage. The flapper only works with Delta Faucet toilets, so it will not be the right option for other toilet types.
11. PlumbCraft Water Saving Universal Fit Toilet Flapper Replacement for 3-Inch Flush Valve Opening, Fits most toilets
Why pick it?
PlumbCraft’s universal-fit toilet flapper is one of the best toilet flappers with an adjustable design. It can be installed on large 3-inch toilet flush valves. The material is resistant to damage from chlorinated and harsh water, which makes it longer lasting and efficient. You can easily follow the given instructions to install this flapper without any difficulty. Users who bought this piece were happy with its dial feature for simple water usage adjustments. The chain is also long enough for convenience, and the flapper allows for quick fits in most toilet tanks.
Drawbacks
The only drawback of this toilet flapper is that it is too wide and not entirely universal according to some customers.
Getting the Best Toilet Flappers
In this saturated market providing innumerable features, getting fooled gets easier when you don’t know your choices. With a view to getting your hands on the soundest of the flappers, this section focuses on various must-have aspects of products. Let’s check them out.
Which Size should I select?
You have to take into consideration what kind of toilet do you use. There are two types of flappers like- 2” and 3”. The first one may be found as flexible and solid framed but the second one is only found in a solid frame. You must choose what kind of flapper is suited for your toilet.
Flappers with flexible frames are a better choice for you. They are made of pure durable rubber and can fit in the up to date flush valve drains. On the contrary, the solid frame is made of hard plastic material that is more durable and solves the leaking problem as well.
Which Type of frame is better?
You have to take into consideration the type of frame as well while buying. Flapper frames are normally of two types – Solid, flexible. The first one is made of pure rubber and the 2nd one is constructed with hard plastic materials.
Normally rubber frames are well suited to all the flush valve toilets as they are flexible. This is also more durable. Solid frames are also useful at some points like protecting the flapper from leakage. You should observe your toilet design and go for the best result.
Type of flapper
All the toilet flappers in the market can be divided into two categories like-adjustable and non-adjustable in terms of your toilet models. Flappers are designed and manufactured commonly for the toilets having the capability of flushing from 5 GPF ( gallons per flush) to 1.28 GPF.
When the requirement is flushing of 1.28 to 1.6 GPF in your toilet then adjustable flappers are the best choice for you. They are made in both styles and sizes. But when the requirement exceeds 3 gallons per flush, non-adjustable ones are better for you. These flappers come in both styles but only in the 2-inch size.
Price
You should keep the price in mind while buying though it is not a big deal for this kind of small purchase. If you want to take it under consideration you may go through the price and the specification you need. Then you will have a clear idea of which product you want.
May be some products allure you with a cheaper price, you should also investigate the product quality. Because some brands may manufacture flappers with low-quality materials and offer you a cheaper price. If you can choose the right one, you will be hassle-free for decades.
Other Things you should keep in mind
Before buying, you should know the material quality of the product. If you are picking an old one you must know the age of the product also though it is not wise to pick an old one. You have to know the installation process. You have to go through a check whether it is a solid frame or flexible.
You have to also consider the age of your toilet. Because the flapper must be compatible with your toilet model. You should keep in mind the warranty deadline (if any included), it may help you in case of repairing.
You should have an idea about the easy removal of the flapper. The flapper normally doesn’t require an extra replacement cost, even if it requires you should think about it. Many companies sell toilet flappers jointly with other parts of the toilet like fill valve which you may not need or maybe good for you. You must decide whether it is necessary for you or not.
FAQ
Q: How long toilet flappers last?
Ans: Toilet flappers last on an average for 4to 5 years. It also depends on your usage. Like if you use a toxic chemical bowl cleaner, the lifetime of the flapper may be squeezed.
Q: Are all toilet flappers the same?
Ans: No. Toilet flappers are found normally in two sizes – 2” and 3 “. It can be measured by measuring the flush valve drain opening at the bottom of the tank. This flush valve system performance varies in shape and size.
Q: How can I be assured that the toilet flapper is leaking?
Ans: If you want to determine it precisely you can drop some color drops and if the color leaks into the bowl after 20-25 minutes then the leakage in the flapper is confirmed.
Conclusion
Toilets may not be a place where you spend a lot of time, but it’s certainly one where you never want an essence of irritation. That’s where toilet flappers love to help you out to keeps yours with no black mold in your toilet bowl.
If money is not a problem and you want the best toilet flappers you should go with the first one. Because Fluidmaster products are more universal and giving you the best features. If you are a Kohler user then Kohler manufactured products give the best toilet flappers you need and also inexpensive. Korky and American standard ones are good too.
